PRECEPTORSHIP PLANNING IS ESSENTIAL TO PERIOPERATIVE NURSING RETENTION: MATCHING TEACHING AND LEARNING STYLES
Abstract
Current nursing shortages along with unsuccessful nursing orientation programs have been a major concern for the past decade because they result in poor retention, reduced quality of patient care, decreased job satisfaction and high financial costs to the organization. Specialty areas, such as the Operating Room (OR), are even more vulnerable due to the stressful working environment and critical care skill set. It has been estimated that approximately 35-65% of new graduates will leave their work place within the first year of employment, lending to the 55% nursing turnover rate. The cost of orientating a new nurse to the perioperative role is estimated to cost between $50,000 and $59,000 US. Thus, it is imperative to improve the orientation experience for both new and senior perioperative nurses. Matching preceptor/preceptee learning styles is one way to enhance job satisfaction levels. This paper revisits the literature on preceptorship and provides suggestions on how to enhance existing orientation programs.
References
Jane J. Baltimore. “The hospital clinical
preceptor: Essential preparation for success”.
Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing
3 (2004) : 133-140.
M. VanOyen Force. “The relationship
between effective nurse managers and nursing
retention”. Journal of Nursing Administration
7 (2005) : 336-341.
J.M.Hayes & A.S. Scott. “Mentoring
partnerships as the wave of the future for new
graduates”. National League of Nursing, Nursing
Education Perspective 28.1 (2007) : 27-29.
Lucy B. Trice, Catherine Brandvold &
Elizabeth Bruno. “Practice and Education:
Partnering to address the perioperative nursing
shortage”. AORN Journal, 86.2 (2007) : 259-
Canadian Nurses Association (2004).
Achieving excellence in professional practice: A
guide to preceptorship and mentoring. Ottawa:
Canadian Nurses Association. Retrieved
September 2008 http://www.canaiic.ca/bookstore
/freepdfs/AchievingExcellence 2004_e.pdf
Margo Kertis. “The One-Minute Preceptor,
A Five-Step Tool to Improve clinical Teaching
Skills”. Journal for Nurses in Staff
Development. 23.5 (2007) : 238-242.
Kristiina Hyrkas & Martha Shoemaker.
“Changes in the preceptor role: re-visiting
preceptors’ perceptions of benefits, rewards,
support and commitment to the role”. Journal
of Advanced Nursing 60.5 (2007) : 513-524.
Judy Anderson. “Orientation with style,
matching teaching/learning style.” Journal for
Nurses in Staff Development 14.4 (1998) :
-197.
Karin Page-Cutrara. “Perioperative nursing
education in Canada: Current and future
perspectives.” Canadian Operating Room
Nursing Journal. 25.1 (2007) : 10-19.
Suzy Lockwood-Rayermann. “Preceptor
leadership style and the nursing practicum.”
Journal of Professional Nursing. 19.1 (2003) :
-37.
Dorothy MacKeracher. Making sense of
adult learning (2nd ed.). (Toronto: University
of Toronto Press 2004) 71-91.
Barbara A. Brunt & Denise J. Kopp.
“Impact of preceptor and orientee learning
styles on satisfaction, a pilot study.” Journal
for Nurses in Staff Development. 23.1(2007) :
-44.
Patricia Cranton. Theoretical Foundations
of Adult Education. In Planning Instruction for
Adult Learners 2nd Ed. (Toronto: Wall &
Emerson 2000) 6-24.
Anne Poonwassie. Facilitating Adult
Education: A Practitioner’s Perspective. In D.H.
Poonwassie & A. Poonwassie (Eds.),
Fundamentals of Adult Education. (Toronto:
Thompson Educational Publishing 2001) 67-
HayGroup, Kolb’s Learning Style
Inventory, Author Unknown, Retrieved April
, 2009, from: http://haygroup.com/tl/
Downloads/Why_People_Learn.pdf
Amanda Henderson, Robyn Fox &
Kristina Malko-Nyhan. “An Evaluation of
Preceptors’ Perceptions of Educational
Preparation and Organizational support for
Their Role.” The Journal of Continuing
Education in Nursing. 37.3 (2006) : 130-136.
The Myers Briggs Foundation. Retrieved
October 2009 http://www.myersbriggs.org/
Rita Dunn, Shirley A. Griggs, Jeffery
Olson, Mark Beasley & Bernard S. Gorman
“A Meta-Analytic Validation of the Dunn and
Dunn Model of Learning-Style Preferences.”
The Journal of Educational Research. 88.6
(1995) :353-362.