LISTEN WHILE YOU WORK? The Attitude of Healthcare Professionals to Music in the OR
Keywords:
music, operating rooms, attitude of health personnel, task performance and analysis, efficiencyAbstract
Although the playing of music is commonplace in the operating theatre, there is nothing in the literature examining whether staff feel this is beneficial. Questionnaires were distributed amongst a random selection of staff in practice at a district general hospital: medical staff from a range of surgical specialities, anaesthetists, and all grades of perioperative staff (nurse/operating department practitioners/healthcare assistants) were encouraged to participate.
There were 121 health professionals in total working in the operating theatres. The authors compared the responses to each question amongst the respondents, to check for the tendency to correlate. Out of the 52 health professionals who responded, 36 stated that music is played in their theatre either every day, or two to three times a week. Only five respondents felt that this was too often. Fifteen percent of medical staff were of the opinion that the nursing staff controlled the choice of music. Nursing staff were almost evenly split in thinking that nursing staff, surgical staff and the whole theatre team controlled the choice of music. The majority of both nursing and medical staff felt that they enjoyed their work more and performed better when music was played in theatre. The study concluded that the majority of theatre staff found listening to music while they work a positive experience. The potential for music to have a distracting or detrimental effect on a minority of individuals should always be considered.
References
Allen K, Blascovich J 1994 Effects of
music on cardiovascular reactivity
among surgeons Journal of the
American Medical Association 272 (11)
-4
Anshel MH, Marisi DQ 1978 Effect of
music and rhythm on physical
performance Research Quarterly 49 (2)
-13
Association for Perioperative Practice
Standards and recommendations
for safe perioperative practice
Harrogate, AfPP
Association of periOperative Registered
Nurses 2014 AORN position statement
on managing distractions and noise
during perioperative patient care
AORN Journal 99 (1) 22-26
Beh HC, Hirst R 1999 Performance on
driving related tasks during music
Ergonomics 42 (8) 1087-98
Dillman D 2000 Mail and internet
surveys: the tailored design method New
York, Wiley
Furnham A, Bradley A 1997 Music
while you work: The differential
distraction of background music on the
cognitive test performance of introverts
and extroverts Applied Cognitive
Psychology 11 445-55
Hargreaves DJ, North AC 1999 The
functions of music in everyday life:
redefining the social in music psychology
Psychology of Music 27 (1) 71-83
Hawksworth C, Asbury AJ, Millar K
Music in theatre: not so
harmonious. A survey of attitudes to
music played in the operating theatre
Anaesthesia 52 (1) 79-83
Henley J 2011 Music for surgery
Available from: http://www.theguardian.
com/lifeandstyle/2011/sep/26/music-forsurgery
[Accessed July 2014]
Korczynski M 2003 Music at work:
Towards a historical overview Folk
Music Journal 8 (3) 314-34
Makama J, Ameh E, Equma S 2010
Music in the operating theatre: opinions
of staff and patients of a Nigerian
teaching hospital African Health
Sciences Journal 10 (4) 386-89
Nilsson U, Unosson M, Rawal N 2005
Stress reduction and analgesia in patients
exposed to calming music
postoperatively: a randomized
controlled trial European Journal of
Anaesthesiology 22 (2) 96-102
North AC, Hargreaves DJ 2000 Musical
preference during and after relaxation
and exercise American Journal of
Psychology 113 43-67
Oldham GR, Cummings A, Mishel LJ et
al 1995 Listen while you work? Qasiexperimental
relations between
personal-stereo headset use and
employee work responses Journal of
Applied Psychology 80 (5) 547-64
Oliver J 1999 Music in theatres British
Journal of Theatre Nursing 9 (10) 460-63
Robb SL, Nichols RJ, Rutan RL et al
The effects of music assisted
relaxation on preoperative anxiety
Journal of Music Therapy XXXII (1) 2-
Turner ML, Fernandez JE, Nelson K et
al 1996 The effect of music amplitude on
the reaction to unexpected visual events
Journal of General Psychology 123 (1)
-62
Ullmann Y, Fodor L, Schwarzberg I et al
The sounds of music in the OR
Injury 39 592-97
Vanderark SD, Ely D 1992 Biochemical
and galvanic responses to music stimuli
by college students in biology and music
Perceptual and Motor Skills 74 (3:2)
-90
Vanderark SD, Ely D 1993 Cortical,
biochemical and galvanic skin responses
to music stimuli of different preference
values by college students in biology and
music Perceptual and Motor Skills 77
-34
Winter MJ, Paskin S, Baker T 1994
Music reduces stress and anxiety of
patients in the surgical holding area
Journal of Post Anaesthesia Nursing 9
(6) 340-43
Woo H 2013 No classical music in my
operating room please Available from:
www.bjuinternational.com/bjui-blog/noclassicalmusic-
in-my-operating-room-ple
ase/ [Accessed March 2014]
World Health Organisation 2009
Surgical safety checklist Available from:
www.who.int/patientsafety/safesurgery/t
ools_resources/en/index.html [Accessed
March 2014]